Skip to the interactive competence maps
Domi Jin / Thoughts and experiments

COLLECTIVE INQUIRY · AN INTERACTIVE ESSAY

Two people, a wider horizonCommon ground, different paths, a question to explore together.

I see education and shared knowledge as part of the foundation of a collaborative society. What becomes possible when two people can see both their common ground and the different paths that brought them there?

Meet Maya and Leo. She facilitates a neighbourhood learning group; he builds its website. Both wonder why people open a lesson and leave before trying the exercise. Follow their exchange below. The people, maps, notes and outcomes are fictional.

Inspect all six topics, provenance, and declared unknowns. Sharing a topic label does not mean sharing definitions, assumptions, or agreement.

Shared topics: Access, Practice · not yet checked
MayaNeighbourhood learning-group facilitator (fictional)
Access1Feedback2Practice3Scheduling4Interfaces5Measurement6
Not yet bridged
LeoLearning-website builder (fictional)
Access1Feedback2Practice3Scheduling4Interfaces5Measurement6
Maya starting familiarity (solid)Leo starting familiarity (dash-dot)Dashed borrowed context (not mastery)Joint question? (dashed link, not proof)

These fictional maps show relative familiarity with six topics. Their size is illustrative, not a measured score.

Choose a topic to compare

Compare perspectives · Access

Access

Common topic · compare the meanings
MayaWorking familiarity
Claim
Participants leave before trying the exercise when they lack unhurried time or a personal device.
Provenance
Fictional workshop conversations after three evening sessions.
Assumption
Access means having quiet time, a usable device, and conditions in which to participate.
Unknown
How often drop-offs come from layout confusion versus household interruptions.
LeoWorking familiarity
Claim
The exercise route loads reliably in under two seconds on mobile browsers.
Provenance
Fictional response-time checks and static-route verification.
Assumption
Access means a resource loads cleanly and can be reached over a standard connection.
Unknown
What happens in a learner’s room or household after the page finishes loading.

Stage 01 · Compare

What the starting maps show

Maya and Leo both care why neighbourhood learners open a lesson and leave before trying the exercise. Both recognise Access and Practice, yet their provenance and assumptions differ.

Common topic ≠ checked understanding: seeing both contours reach working familiarity on Access only tells you they use the same word—not that they mean the same thing, share a question, or agree on a claim.

Showing starting competence maps for Maya and Leo. Access and Practice are shared topics, not yet checked.
02

WHAT CHANGES THROUGH AN EXCHANGE?

Shared vocabulary is not mutual understanding

1. Common topic

Maya and Leo both recognise Access and Practice. On a map, their contours reach working familiarity on the same spoke, yet Maya means time, quiet space, and a shared phone while Leo means a page that loads. Overlap on a label only marks where a check needs to happen.

2. Understanding a perspective

Can I explain your point in a way you recognise? Here, each person tries to interpret a specific note from the other. Dashed marks show this borrowed context. Their starting maps stay unchanged: a brief exchange does not establish lasting mastery.

3. Shared question & method

Aligning on a question coordinates what to test next without forcing agreement on an answer or merging distinct experience. On the map, the joint frontier extends outward as a dashed question link—not a filled territory of settled knowledge.

4. Examined provisional contribution

A contribution can report an encouraging, mixed, or not-supported outcome. What makes it useful to others is keeping its source, scope, contributors, and remaining unknown intact rather than polishing a claim into certainty.

03

WRITINGS IN THIS COLLECTION

Between individual learning and working together

This interactive note sits between 03 · Human Agency and 04 · Working Together, complementing the separate 3D language-model knowledge boundary sketch. It draws on three essays in the local archive: